Dylan
Smith

Centre-back · age 20 · Scotland · 6 ft 1 in (1.85 m) · contract to May 2027

Apps
9
Goals
2
Assists
0
Rating
6.75
2026/27

Matthew
Shiels

Centre-back · age 26 · Scotland · 6 ft 0 in (1.83 m) · contract to May 2028

Apps
9
Goals
0
Assists
0
Rating
6.21
2026/27
Change Smith
Change Shiels

Attributes

2025/26 and 2026/27 · rated out of 99

Dylan SmithMatthew Shiels
SHO26 · 19CRE8 · 16PAS48 · 43DEF26 · 35PHY35 · 49
26Shooting19
8Creating16
48Passing43
26Defending35
35Physical49

Each number out of 99, against the players each was rated with. Rated against different pools: Dylan Smith against League One, Matthew Shiels against Championship. A 90 in one league isn’t a 90 in another.

Per 90 minutes

League matches · 2025/26 and 2026/27

Dylan SmithMatthew Shiels
2,083 minutes3,886 minutes
6.43Average rating6.33
0.09Goalsper 900.02
0.00Assistsper 900.05
0.22Shotsper 900.37
0.04Shots on targetper 900.12
20%Shot accuracy31%
–Big chances createdper 900.02
0.13Key passesper 900.23
–Dribbles completedper 900.46
24.6Passesper 9026.2
76%Pass accuracy71%
1.60Tackles + interceptionsper 901.74
43%Duels won41%
2.07Aerials wonper 903.40
2.72Clearancesper 904.03
0.26Blocksper 900.39
0.65Fouls wonper 900.42
0.04Dispossessedper 900.07
45%Won, in his games22%
1.52Points a game, in his games0.98

Where they play

Positions in their recent starts

Dylan SmithMatthew Shiels
Dylan Smith
CBRBRM

Centre-back 80% · Right-back 18% · Right midfielder 3%

Matthew Shiels
CBLBLMRMDMCM

Centre-back 54% · Left-back 29% · Left midfielder 11%

Career

League seasons in the competitions we cover

Dylan SmithMatthew Shiels
69League apps146
3League goals6
4League assists7
0.04Goals per game0.04
1311Minutes per goalfewer is better1948
Clean sheets a season, at the same age
  1. 3
    14
    age 16
  2. 3
    6
    age 17
  3. 7
    1
    187
    age 18
  4. 6
    1
    226
    age 19
  5. 3
    2
    98
    age 20
  6. 6
    30
    age 21
  7. 2
    25
    age 22
  8. 2
    25
    age 23
  9. 9
    36
    age 24
  10. 0
    9
    age 25

Each pair: clean sheets above, league games below. Lined up by his age when each season began.

The tale of the tape

League careers in the competitions we cover

Dylan SmithMatthew Shiels
20
Age
26
6 ft 1 in (1.85 m)
Height
6 ft 0 in (1.83 m)
Right
Foot
–
May 2027
Contract to
May 2028
5
League seasons
8
0
League titles
0
–
Last move
Free transfer, 2025

League matches in the competitions we cover. Cups, Europe and internationals aren’t included. Fees are reported figures, credited on each player’s page.