Barnsley 3–5 Milton Keynes Dons
- Conor Hourihane 82′ · assist Luke Berry
- Conor Hourihane 87′ · assist Dale Jennings
- Devante Cole 90+1′ · assist Dale Jennings
- Benik Afobe 33′ · assist M. Randall
- S. Carruthers 45+1′ · assist George Baldock
- Dele Alli 52′ · assist S. Carruthers
- Will Grigg 71′
- Ben Reeves 79′ · assist Daniel Powell
Saturday 13 September at 15:00 · Oakwell Stadium · Referee C. Boyeson