York City 2–2 Carlisle United
- Luke Summerfield 72′ pen
- Josh Carson 74′ · assist Emile Sinclair
- Tom Miller 26′ · assist Alex Gilliead
- Troy Archibald-Henville 42′ · assist Michael Raynes
Saturday 19 September at 15:00 · Bootham Crescent · Referee Nick Kinseley