Dylan
MacDonald

Right-back · age 23 · Scotland · 5 ft 10 in (1.78 m) · contract to May 2027

Apps
13
Goals
0
Assists
0
Rating
6.24
2026/27

Matthew
Shiels

Centre-back · age 26 · Scotland · 6 ft 0 in (1.83 m) · contract to May 2028

Apps
9
Goals
0
Assists
0
Rating
6.21
2026/27
Change MacDonald
Change Shiels

Attributes

All seasons · rated out of 99

Dylan MacDonaldMatthew Shiels
SHO13 · 17CRE28 · 14PAS48 · 23DRI39 · 14DEF41 · 19PHY31 · 28
13Shooting17
28Creating14
48Passing23
39Dribbling14
41Defending19
31Physical28

Each number out of 99, against the players each was rated with. Rated against different pools: Dylan MacDonald against League One, Matthew Shiels against Championship. A 90 in one league isn’t a 90 in another.

Per 90 minutes

League matches · All seasons

Dylan MacDonaldMatthew Shiels
5,056 minutes11,687 minutes
6.51Average rating6.33
0.04Goalsper 900.05
0.05Assistsper 900.05
0.07Shotsper 900.12
0.02Shots on targetper 900.04
25%Shot accuracy31%
–Big chances createdper 900.01
0.28Key passesper 900.08
0.32Dribbles completedper 900.15
16.9Passesper 908.7
74%Pass accuracy71%
0.87Tackles + interceptionsper 900.58
39%Duels won41%
1.66Aerials wonper 901.13
1.78Clearancesper 901.34
0.21Blocksper 900.13
0.98Fouls wonper 900.18
0.11Dispossessedper 900.02
31%Won, in his games25%
1.23Points a game, in his games1.00

Where they play

Positions in their recent starts

Dylan MacDonaldMatthew Shiels
Dylan MacDonald
RBLBCBCM

Right-back 69% · Left-back 22% · Centre-back 7%

Matthew Shiels
CBLBLMRMDMCM

Centre-back 54% · Left-back 29% · Left midfielder 11%

Career

League seasons in the competitions we cover

Dylan MacDonaldMatthew Shiels
62League apps146
2League goals6
3League assists7
0.03Goals per game0.04
2528Minutes per goalfewer is better1948
Clean sheets a season, season by season
  1. 1
    7
    19/20
  2. 1
    6
    20/21
  3. 0
    2
    08
    21/22
  4. 6
    30
    22/23
  5. 2
    25
    23/24
  6. 6
    2
    2925
    24/25
  7. 5
    9
    2036
    25/26
  8. 4
    0
    139
    26/27

Each pair: clean sheets above, league games below. By the year each season began.

The tale of the tape

League careers in the competitions we cover

Dylan MacDonaldMatthew Shiels
23
Age
26
5 ft 10 in (1.78 m)
Height
6 ft 0 in (1.83 m)
Right
Foot
–
May 2027
Contract to
May 2028
4
League seasons
8
0
League titles
0
Fee undisclosed, 2024
Last move
Free transfer, 2025

League matches in the competitions we cover. Cups, Europe and internationals aren’t included. Fees are reported figures, credited on each player’s page.