Chicago Fire 2–2 Sporting KC
- Brian McBride 13′ · assist Wilman Conde
- Brian McBride 20′ · assist Cuauhtémoc Blanco Bravo
- Luis Argudo 78′ · assist Claudio Lopez
- Luis Argudo 89′ · assist Michael Harrington
Sunday 19 April at 01:30 · Toyota Park · Referee Hilario Grajeda